There are many positives and negatives to having both roses and tulips. They both make lovely cut flowers. However, the type of care that they need is a bit different. They also possess different spiritual meanings. It is hard to say which one is better because they both have pros and cons.
You will find that roses and tulips have unique characteristics that will charm and delight you. From their interesting histories to their unique growing patterns, roses and tulips are full of beauty. They make excellent cut flowers and members of any garden.
When deciding between roses and tulips, it is best to see how they are related. It will be in their pros and cons, symbolic meaning, and plant botany that you can best understand these beautiful flowers.
Pros and Cons of Having Roses
Roses have many great qualities. They add beauty to any garden. There are many species of roses which include tea roses, climbing roses, and rose bushes. The difference between rose breeds can vary in the size, shape, and scent of the flowers.
You can tweak your rose garden to include the type of blooms you want, whether it is a brightly colored rose or one with an extra sweet scent. Some have no scent at all.
Plus, when you cut the blooms, you will get many more roses especially if you practice deadheading. Deadheading is the process of cutting off the blooms that are past their prime. When you do this, it will stimulate your rose to produce even more flowers. So, if you would like a weekly bouquet of flowers during the growing season, roses are a good choice for you.
Another added benefit of roses is that they are disease-resistant.
They are happy in warm weather
The con of having roses include the fact that they are very finicky and sometimes difficult to keep alive. While they may be disease resistant, they have specific needs when it comes to pruning and soil quality. They also need an accurate and consistent watering schedule.
Another con is that they have thorns. If you are not down to get pricked every once in a while, you should probably choose another flower for your life.
It also must be said that they are a lot of work, especially because you can get so many flowers from one plant. You have to be diligent in pruning and harvesting the flowers from your roses.
Tulip bulbs can be planted in fall or winter, while roses require a warmer climate to grow.
Pros and Cons of Having Tulips
One huge pro, when compared to roses, is that tulips are quite easy to care for. They require little maintenance. They also make great potted plants. You can even grow them indoors.
Another pro of having tulips is their ability to grow in cool weather. They are one of the first flowers of spring. They are a welcome respite after the dark winter months.
Another positive attribute is that they will come back year after year and expand to grow more flowers. This may mean you need to take time to separate them, but they will bring you joy and beauty for many years without needing to put as much work in as you would when caring for roses.
A con to having tulips in your garden is that many pests are drawn to them and very well may eat your tulips. You will want to protect them from deer and squirrels especially.
Another con is that while they make beautiful cut flowers, they do not last very long in a bouquet, especially when compared to roses.
Additionally, tulips do not have the same sweet scent as a rose does. So, if you are looking for a fragrant flower, roses are for you.
Roses Are The Traditional Symbol of Love
Roses have been a symbol of love from the times of the ancient Arabs and ancient Greeks to the Victorian Era and the modern-day. It is even referenced in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. “A rose by any other name would smell as sweet…”
Roses are the traditional flower that is given in romantic relationships, especially on Valentine’s Day. It is customary to give and receive a bouquet of red roses specifically.
Roses can also be a symbol of friendship, trust, and connection. They are wonderful flowers to add a romantic flair to any relationship.
Tulips Represent Happiness and Good Fortune
Tulips will bring about joy and luck. Specifically yellow tulips. Humans have had a love affair for thousands of years. They have been especially well-loved in ancient Turkey and Persia. They were said to bring good fortune, happiness, and deep affection.
This connotation is possibly connected to Tulipmania in the Netherlands. Tulipmania was a time for the Dutch in which they heavily traded rare species of tulips. During the years 1636 to 1637, tulips were a form of currency. This can explain especially why they are symbols of good fortune.
Some say tulips are also representative of perfect or deep love. So, like roses, giving a bouquet of tulips can also be romantic.
Which One Is Better?
After reviewing the pros and cons, and after understanding the symbolic meanings of roses and tulips, the choice is really up to you. They both have the capacity to bring beauty and joy to any home. A bouquet of roses will smell lovely. A bouquet of yellow tulips is sure to brighten any mood.
You want to add roses to your life if you are looking for an experience with gardening. They need a lot of tender loving care. Plus, they are great in the garden if you are looking to make cut flower bouquets all growing season long. They will rapidly produce roses as they mature.
Roses are the choice if you are looking to spruce up your romantic life. Cut flower bouquets of roses can be more expensive than ones of tulips. So, tulips are your choice if you want high-quality flowers without breaking the bank.
When it comes to the tulip, it requires less garden maintenance, and they are prolific symbols of spring. They will always add joy to your life, especially after a long winter. Their symbolic meaning is that of happiness and good fortune, which is another great reason to keep tulips around.
Where to Buy Tulips and Roses
When you are going to purchase any plant, you want to be sure you are purchasing flowers that are well-cared for. That means go with an experienced, organic grower. You do not want goods that have been sprayed with harmful chemicals.
You can buy tulips and roses in a nursery or a florist shop. They are also often found at garden supply centers, hardware stores, and grocery stores. You can also find them at your local farmers’ market.
- Dozen Roses Bouquet: $20 to $100
- Dozen Tulips Bouquet: $10 to $70
- Rose Plant: $20 to $100
- Tulip Plant: $10 to $100
The prices vary widely as there are certain cultivars of each plant that are rare. Buying a rare species will always cost more. So will buying from a high-end vendor or florist.
Growing tulips and roses are fairly easy. They have some different needs to consider as well, as all flowers do. Here are some tips for growing tulips and roses.
- prefer morning sun with 6 hours of daylight
- more blooms as the plants mature
- fertilize regularly
- hard prune in late winter/early spring
- well-draining soil with the ability to retain moisture, like loam.
- prefer morning sun or shade
- separate seasonally as more bulbs form
- feed when planting
- well-draining soil that won’t retain moisture (sandy, acidic soil does well)
- plant bulbs in early spring or fall.
- Over 150 species ranging in colors across the entire rainbow.
- Over 3000 different varieties with colors ranging from deep maroon to bright yellow.
- Both will bring glorious hues of red, pink, yellow, orange, and more. They are full of beauty.
Understanding Tulip Botany: Mini-Lesson
Another great way to understand a plant is to understand its botany. Botany is the study of plants where the focus is on classifying, identifying plant structures, and understanding the ecological importance of plants.
Tulips are in the plant family, Liliaceae, the lily family. They are bulbiferous, herbaceous, perennial (comes back every year) flowers.
One plant will have an average of five to six leaves at the base, sometimes more, sometimes less. The plant will grow one stem that will produce one flower per plant.
The flowers are bell-shaped containing three sepals and three petals. The leaves and stems are green and smooth.
There are 75 species of tulips containing both true and hybrid flowers.
Tip: Plant lots of tulips for the ultimate tulip garden, since you only get one flower per plant.
Understanding Rose Botany: Mini-Lesson
Roses are members of the Rosaceae family, better known as the rose family. They are hardy. They will come in the form of shrubs or climbing bushes. They, like tulips, are perennial.
The flowers contain five to ten petals and five sepals. The petals are of different sizes but form a similar structure around the pistils and stamen of the plant.
They will have a cup-like shape and spiral outwards, slightly overlapping one another. The pistils and stamens are hidden beneath the petals and sepals.
The stems are sometimes thorny. The leaves are sharply toothed with oval leaflets. They alternate and are pinnately compound.
There are over 300 species of roses.
Tip: Trellice climbing roses to support the plants’ structure.
How to Choose the Species that is best for You
When considering tulips and roses, there are many varieties to choose from. When choosing which type of roses or tulips you want to purchase, you may consider their color.
Both roses and tulips come in a wide array of colors, so you can have any color that brings you joy or will match your aesthetic.
You may want to have a trellis in your yard where you can add beautiful climbing roses. Perhaps you have an empty shady spot, perfect for planting tulips.
If you want flowers that bloom all summer long, you want to add roses to your garden. If you want flowers to enjoy in early spring, choose tulips.
Both will be useful if you are looking to experiment with making flower essences. You can also eat the petals of both roses and tulips.
We advise you to be sure that the flowers you are ingesting are free from chemicals like herbicides or pesticides.
The final consideration applies to what kind of energy you want to bring into your space. Tulip flowers will bless your home with luck and positivity. Roses for love and friendship. If you plant these flowers, they will bring years of positivity to your space.
Roses and Tulips in General
Roses and tulips are prolific members of the flower world. These flowers make excellent additions to your garden. They also make excellent gifts in the form of a plant or bouquet.
Tulips are great flowers for the early spring and cool weather, while roses are more suited for warm weather.
Additionally, they require different maintenance methods and have different soil requirements. These factors are but a couple when it comes to the differences between roses and tulips.
Another consideration when weighing the rose vs the tulip is the symbolic meaning. Give roses to signify your love for another person, especially a romantic partner. Give tulips to bring happiness and good fortune to your home or the home of a loved one.
As you can see, roses and tulips have different qualities but both are worthwhile. Whether you want to plant and enjoy gardening or you just want to look at a beautiful flower, roses and tulips will provide you with joy.
The choice is yours if you would like to have roses or tulips in your life. We say, hey, why not both?